Florida is more than a destination of sun-soaked beaches and calm oceans. It’s a place where culinary traditions take center stage, blending the bounty of the sea with the state’s cultural richness to create unforgettable dining experiences. Across Anna Maria Island and beyond, Florida cuisine bursts with flavors that reflect the state’s subtropical climate, coastal waters, and access to fresh ingredients.
Whether you crave fresh-caught seafood or a casual alfresco meal by the shore, this region presents a culinary journey like no other.
Florida Cuisine
Topsail Steamer Seafood
Topsail Steamer redefines the way locals and visitors experience coastal seafood with its unique blend of tradition and convenience. By offering customizable steam pots, it allows families and friends to savor the flavors of Florida cuisine from the comfort of their own homes. Each pot, named a “Bay Bucket,” includes a mix of red bliss potatoes, sweet corn, butter, cocktail sauce, and a variety of fresh seafood. The concept is simple: you build your combination, take it home, steam it, and enjoy an unmatched family-style feast. The freshness of the ingredients is paramount at Topsail Steamer — a nod to the culinary priorities of South Florida cuisine. In keeping with Florida’s reputation for innovation and creativity in its dining scene, Topsail’s no-fuss preparation ensures that you get to enjoy every bite without the hassle of cleaning or prepping raw seafood. These customized pots showcase the core of what Florida’s coastal cuisine does best: celebrating the ocean’s freshest offerings in a communal, laid-back setting.
Sandbar Seafood + Spirits
Few dining establishments embody the spirit of Florida cuisine as well as Sandbar Seafood + Spirits. Located right on the beach, this iconic restaurant offers the ultimate Florida experience of dining with your toes in the sand. Known for its Gulf-to-table approach, the Sandbar focuses on sustainability and seasonal offerings, serving dishes that highlight the best of South Florida cuisine. The menu features freshly caught Gulf seafood, blended with creative culinary techniques that elevate simple ingredients into extraordinary meals.
From perfectly seared fish filets to shellfish prepared with tropical-inspired flavors, each dish is a testament to the region’s culinary prowess. The Sandbar also provides a stunning backdrop with breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico, making it a popular choice for romantic dinners and celebratory meals alike. While enjoying your meal, you’ll experience an atmosphere steeped in the traditions and flavors of Florida.
The Waterfront Restaurant
On Anna Maria Island, The Waterfront Restaurant delivers a dining experience that combines old-world charm with contemporary cuisine. Situated in a historic cottage originally built in 1922, this restaurant captures the essence of Florida cuisine with its focus on fresh, locally sourced products. The Waterfront is known for its partnership with Anna Maria Island Fishing Charters, ensuring that seafood on your plate has a traceable journey from the ocean. While the menu updates seasonally to feature the freshest available ingredients, the emphasis remains on classic preparations that let natural flavors shine. Whether you’re sampling their tender grouper filets or other specialties like stone crab claws, every bite reflects a careful balance of tradition and creativity. Even the restaurant’s setting pays homage to the past; the design of the space honors its heritage as “Lorraine Cottage,” seamlessly weaving its history into the dining experience.
The Ugly Grouper
For a more lively and casual take on Florida cuisine, The Ugly Grouper offers an experience brimming with character. This entirely outdoor dining venue is a favorite among families and groups seeking a laid-back atmosphere. From its welcoming vibe to its robust menu focused on freshly prepared local seafood, The Ugly Grouper brings approachable, vibrant flavors to the forefront. Signature dishes center on seafood, particularly grouper prepared in a variety of ways. They also cater to diverse tastes with offerings like tacos and hearty sandwiches. Beyond the food, the restaurant’s lively atmosphere heightens the appeal, with daily live music, games, and plenty of space to stretch out under the open sky. Whether you’re stopping in for lunch or an evening meal with friends, The Ugly Grouper is a colorful reminder of the state’s rich culinary traditions and relaxed sensibility.
Waterfront Rentals on Anna Maria Island
Flamingo Bay
Flamingo Bay offers a private retreat where vintage island charm meets contemporary comfort. Located on the bay side of Anna Maria Island, this luxurious four-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bathroom beach house epitomizes upscale waterfront living. The home includes spacious bedrooms and stunning sunrises right outside your door, all while being a short distance from the area’s top attractions. Guests can enjoy direct access to the beach, along with scenic vistas from the master suite and back patio, which overlooks sparkling bay waters. Flamingo Bay’s design makes it an ideal spot for families staying on Anna Maria Island, where relaxation meets daily convenience. You’ll love returning to its peaceful surroundings after indulging in the island’s culinary scene.
Dolphin’s Run
Dolphin’s Run elevates the experience of staying in Anna Maria Island beachfront rentals. This three-story home features panoramic water views from nearly every room, bringing the beauty of Anna Maria right to your windows. The open layout connects living spaces to a full-length balcony perfect for watching the sun dip into the horizon at the end of a long day. Inside, the property combines contemporary design with thoughtful details, ensuring a memorable stay for both families and couples. Bedrooms are airy and welcoming, featuring private balconies that provide a true sanctuary for guests. Whether you’re stepping out for a morning coffee overlooking the bay or winding down with a meal prepared in the spacious kitchen, Dolphin’s Run epitomizes Florida living at its finest. Its location also makes it a favorite choice for those eager to experience top-tier dining, including the restaurants that define South Florida cuisine.
Plan Your Visit
Our AMI vacation rentals can’t be beat – check out our full inventory!
The Beach House
For those who dream of waking up to uninterrupted views of the Gulf of Mexico, The Beach House delivers an unforgettable stay. Located north of Pine Avenue, this luxurious home offers the perfect blend of Old Florida charm and modern upgrades. Designed with families and groups in mind, the three-bedroom house features a spacious layout with direct access to the Gulf and a private pool for added indulgence. Inside, the home is both stylish and functional, with an open-plan living area that seamlessly connects to the pool deck. With outdoor dining spaces, lounge chairs, and turquoise waters just steps away, there’s no better place to enjoy a meal prepared with Florida’s rich bounty of fresh ingredients. Whether dining at home or venturing to one of the local eateries, The Beach House serves as a gateway to some of the best culinary and scenic experiences Anna Maria Island has to offer.
Stay With Duncan Real Estate
When it comes to Anna Maria Island rentals, Duncan Real Estate offers exceptional options for those looking to immerse themselves in this coastal paradise. Whether you’re dining on fresh seafood at one of the island’s many renowned restaurants or unwinding in a waterside property like Flamingo Bay, Dolphin’s Run, or The Beach House, Duncan Real Estate ensures a seamless experience. From breathtaking waterfront views to convenient access to Florida cuisine and culture, a stay in one of our Anna Maria Island vacation rentals is defined by relaxation and exploration. Duncan Real Estate takes pride in providing visitors with unforgettable stays that capture the unique charm and beauty of the region. With properties tailored to every traveler’s needs, there’s no better way to explore the best of Anna Maria Island. Let Duncan Real Estate help you discover the flavors of Florida and the warm embrace of beachfront living, so every memory you make here is one to savor.
