Search Results > Property Detail

The Shady Mermaid

Address: 5706 Carissa Street | Type: Home | Location: Holmes Beach

Bedrooms: 2

Bathrooms: 2

Sleeps: 6

Has Pool

View Gallery Virtual Tour View Location

This property has been viewed 29 times in the last 3 days

Select your arrival date

Select your departure date

Reserve your stay

Arrival Date

Departure Date

Overview ↑↓

Welcome to The Shady Mermaid! A luxury ground-level vacation home just a 3-minute walk from the beach! With two bedrooms and two bathrooms, this rental sleeps up to six guests. You and your guests can sit back, relax, watch movies, and connect over effortless conversations in the living area. Top of the range, fully equipped kitchen has ample counter space, gas cook top and oven, extra-large fridge/freezer and wine cooler making meal prep a breeze. There is also a wet bar in the dining area with two cooler drawers, a large butler's kitchen with a large freezer. Delight in your delicious island-inspired homemade meals or Anna Maria Island take-out at the indoor or outdoor dining table, where you can also enjoy the Island breeze.

The primary bedroom offers a calming atmosphere perfect for catching up on much-needed sleep and has a TV for late-night entertainment. The second bedroom is perfect for another couple and has plenty of closet space for vacation attire and beach necessities. The primary bedroom has a bathroom which features a soaking tub and walk-in shower. The guest bathroom has a walk-in shower. There is also a baby monitor in the property.

Relax in your private backyard oasis, where you and your guests can make a splash in the pool which also functions as a spa and you relax in one of the many seating areas. There is a BBQ grill perfect for grilling locally caught seafood. Explore the beautiful beaches Anna Maria Island offers, swim in the warm turquoise waters, and feel the sugary sand cover your feet. Afterward, browse the fantastic boutiques, coffee shops in Holmes Beach or head to any local restaurants for delicious treats and fresh seafood! Hop on the free trolley and explore the island! Anna Maria Island has many guided tours. Kayak or paddleboard the bay and the calm Gulf of Mexico, where you might even encounter some wildlife!

HIGHLIGHTS

•    1406 sq. ft.
•    Private Pool/Spa (12x7 ft.)
•    Tiki Hut
•    0.1 mile from beach access
•    0.2 miles from bay access

BEDROOMS

•    Sleeps 6
•    Primary Bedroom: King Casper Mattress
•    Second Bedroom: King
•    Sleeper Sofa: Queen

BATHROOM

•    Primary Bathroom: Spa Soaking Tub and Walk-in Shower
•    Second Bathroom: Walk-in Shower

EXTERIOR

After a long day at the beach, head back to The Shady Mermaid and take advantage of its beautiful outdoor scape. Take a dip in the crystal-clear private heated pool/spa. There is a gas grill and outdoor dining spot to enjoy a bite to eat in a beautiful, tropical landscape. Also, a large Tiki Hut with bar, loungers and outdoor TV where you can enjoy the Game.

Optional pool heat up to 86º F is available from October to April at $100/week.
Pool equipment is locked for safety and controls must not be tampered with. Pool alarms are mandated per city licensing ordinance and cannot be disarmed. Pools are professionally serviced weekly. Debris due to tropical climate might occur in between service days. Pool equipment does not run 24 hours and water temperature can vary as pool heaters operate ONLY when the pool pump is running. Weather conditions may affect the temperature of the pool. When the ambient temperature falls below 60 degrees F, the pool heater may not function and even switch off.
Duncan Real Estate will expedite repairs of reported malfunctions, but no refund will be made for circumstances beyond our control.

Minimum stay: 7 nights and Maximum occupancy: 6 people

There are parking spaces for two cars at The Shady Mermaid. Also, a Golf Cart parking space with outlet.

Following items are provided during your stay.

Amenities:
3-in-1 soap in each full bathroom
Hand soap
Laundry detergent sheets
Dish soap
Trash bags
Cleaning Spray
Dishwasher Pods

Linens:
2 bath towels per guest occupancy
1 beach towels per guest occupancy
1.5. wash cloths per guest occupancy
2 hand towels per bathroom
1 bath mat per full bathroom
2 kitchen towels
2 kitchen wash cloths

Starter Supplies:
2 rolls of toilet paper per bathroom
1 roll of paper towels
1 new sponge

Beach Amenities:
2-6 beach chairs *based on occupancy
Beach umbrella
Beach cart in private homes
Cooler

Please keep in mind that you are vacationing in a residential area. Please be a good neighbor by keeping the noise to a respectful level during the day and night. Excessive and unreasonable noise can deprive neighbors of the peaceful enjoyment of their private property.

VRC: 23-000116

Amenities ↑↓

• Bath Towels

• Beach Amenities

• Beach Towels

• Blender

• Board Games

• Breakfast Bar

• Butler's Pantry

• Central A/C

• Central Heat

• Cleaning Kit

• Cookware

• Deck

• Dining Table

• Dishwasher

• Drip Coffee maker

• Dryer

• Exterior Outlet

• Fire Extinguisher

• First Aid Kit

• Free Parking

• Garbage Disposal

• Ground level

• Hair Dryer

• Hangers

• High Chair

• High Speed WIFI

• Hot Water

• Ice Maker

• Iron

• Ironing Board

• Keurig

• King bed

• Lock Box Entry

• Luxury Rental

• Microwave

• Outdoor Dining

• Outdoor Games

• Pack N Play

• 2 Parking Spots

• Patio

• Pool

• Pool Alarms

• Private Pool

• Propane Grill

• Quality Linens

• Queen Sleeper

• Refrigerator

• Self Check In

• Smoke Alarm

• Spa/Hot Tub

• Stove

• Toaster

• 4 TV

• TV Streaming Only

• Washer

• Wine Fridge

Request Info

Name(Required)

Email(Required)

Phone

Message(Required)

Reviews ↑↓

Submit a Review for The Shady Mermaid

Rental Review

Your Name(Required)

Enter your name as used on your reservation so we can validate your stay with us. This will NOT display on the website.

Your Email(Required)

Please enter your email address in case we need to contact you. This will NOT display on the website.

Public Information

The fields below may be publicly displayed on our website.

Display Name(Required)

Please enter your name as you wish it to appear on the website. Use initials if you wish privacy.

Review Title(Required)

Enter a short phrase to describe your rental experience.

Arrival Date(Required)

Enter the date you checked in for this rental. Select the month, day and year.

Month

Day

Year

Rating (1-5)(Required)

Select based on the # star rating you would give this property. 5 being the best.

Review

Leave your comments about this rental property.

The cutest house, so upscale!

Review Date: July 30, 2026

Vacation Date: July 6, 2026

"The cutest house, so upscale. Backyard was the cutest. Beach access close by and conveniently located to shops and food. Loved it so much, was sad to leave.

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

This is the third vacation in AMI and this was by far the nicest property we have rented!

Review Date: May 21, 2026

Vacation Date: April 24, 2026

"Property was perfect for our vacation. Very clean with awesome backyard setting with a pool. We spent a lot of time in the pool and covered deck area. The house was very clean with great kitchen and high end appliances. We continued to be impressed with all the attention to detail by the owners. It had all the amenities to enjoy the beach (wagon, chairs, umbrella, coolers) which was a very short walk to public access. Included some backyard games to spend time outside. Location was excellent with shops, restaurants, and beach all within walking distance. We were impressed with everything about this property and would definitely rent this property again in future visits. This is the third vacation in AMI and this was by far the nicest property we have rented. Highly recommended to anyone looking for a nice location to enjoy AMI, pool, beach, and relaxation.

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

The backyard area was exceptional, a very special place!

Review Date: March 3, 2026

Vacation Date: February 21, 2026

"Beautiful property, appliances and decor all high end. Very well furnished, as ll we needed. The backyard area was exceptional, a very special place where we enjoyed the pool/spa even in cool weather.

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

Amazing home, closer to ocean!

Review Date: August 13, 2025

Vacation Date: August 4, 2025

"We were treated fantastic by Duncan. Had some problems with the original home we booked and they upgraded us to an amazing home, closer to ocean, gave us a little gift for the inconvenience also. Will for sure be coming back to the Sandy Mermaid home. That place was my oasis for 9 wonderful days.

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

We had the best week at The Shady Mermaid!

Review Date: August 4, 2025

Vacation Date: July 25, 2025

"We had the best week at The Shady Mermaid. A beautifully appointed home. Relaxing, peaceful, well stocked and very easy access to the beach and other island activities. We will absolutely rent again!

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

This was a lovely cottage!

Review Date: July 21, 2025

Vacation Date: July 13, 2025

"This was a lovely cottage! Very spacious, upgraded kitchen and bathrooms and very cool backyard. The pool is a smaller pool, more to just sit and chill in, not something kids can swim in, but we still had a blast. It was a very easy 5 minute walk to the beach and the beach was never crowded, it was fantastic! Look forward to coming back!!!

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

The Shady Mermaid was extraordinary!

Review Date: March 29, 2025

Vacation Date: March 22, 2025

"My friend group and I travel annually to Anna Maria Island, so between the five of us we've rented dozens and dozens of vacation rentals over the years on the island. This home, The Shady Mermaid, was extraordinary! We've found over the years that Duncan Properties by far provide the greater experience. We've rented from the other companies on the island and their homes don't compare. They are not as well maintained and they lack essential items. Duncan thinks of everything, every detail. They are wonderful!

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

Just a few minutes walk to the beach!

Review Date: July 26, 2024

Vacation Date: June 15, 2024

"We just spent 5 nights at the Shady Mermaid property, and were thoroughly impressed with how appointed it was. Little details that are normally overlooked or ignored with AirBNB/VRBO properties were not at that property. There were dishwashing pods, plenty of pots/pans and cooking utensils, trash bags, toiletries for the bathroom, and of course all the items one would want for a trip to the beach. Every last detail of this place was impressive. There is a tablet on the wall that controls everything from lighting to fans and music (living room and on the back porch by the pool). The kitchen appliances are extremely high end and there is plenty of refrigerator/freezer space for anything you may need. It’s well located too, just a few minute walk to the beach and there are several stores/restaurants within a couple blocks. And best of all, the mattresses were fantastic - we all slept great. This is by far the most impressive property we have stayed in our several years of coming to AMI when it comes to the build out and the details I mentioned. Everything looks new and follows the same theme. Perfect spot for a family of 4-5 or just a couple. We will be back!

Reviewed By: Duncan guest

Beautiful place!

Review Date: July 26, 2024

Vacation Date: June 8, 2024

"Beautiful place! The backyard was our favorite part and it was so nice & quiet!

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

Paradise Found at the Shady Mermaid

Review Date: July 23, 2024

Vacation Date: April 27, 2024

"Our stay at the beautiful Shady Mermaid on Anna Maria Island was nothing short of perfect! From the moment we arrived, we were enchanted by the charming coastal decor and the warm, welcoming atmosphere of the home. The house was impeccably clean and inviting, with every modern amenity we could have asked for. The kitchen was so state-of-the-art that I almost felt guilty microwaving leftovers – almost. The living room was perfect for our group, complete with a giant TV and a cozy couch, making it the ideal retreat for relaxing after a day of island adventures. The bedrooms were incredibly comfortable, and our kids actually went to bed willingly – a miracle in itself. We especially appreciated the master suite, which felt like a private sanctuary with its own luxurious bathroom. But the true pièce de résistance was the backyard. The pool was a sparkling gem that became the centerpiece of our vacation. The kids transformed into little (some shady) mermaids, while we adults took turns soaking up the sun. The outdoor grill area turned us into BBQ masters, and the patio was the perfect spot for morning coffee in the sun and evening cocktails under the stars. The location was unbeatable – just a short walk to the pristine beaches of Anna Maria Island. We loved exploring the local shops and dining at the fantastic nearby restaurants. The provided beach chairs, towels, and toys made our beach days effortless and fun. In short, Shady Mermaid exceeded all our expectations and provided the ideal backdrop for a memorable summer vacation. We left feeling relaxed, rejuvenated, and already dreaming of our return. Five stars, two thumbs up, and a heartfelt thank you to our wonderful hosts for sharing their slice of paradise with us!

Reviewed By: Sheila

Luxurious with amazing pool close to the beach

Review Date: April 29, 2024

Vacation Date: April 1, 2024

"We are regular travelers and would rate The Shady Mermaid as one of the most luxurious, best located, and cleanest of all the places we have stayed. The home is very modern and had next-level amenities from the chef kitchen to the outdoor patio. It’s in a quiet location with a beautiful pool and gorgeous outdoor area perfect for a couple looking for a romantic getaway with plenty of privacy. For us, the outdoor area - and especially the super warm pool - was a phenomenal play area for our young kids. The location was an easy, short walk to the beach. Our hosts had everything available for a family with young kids - including a wagon for the beach trip. Would highly recommend this wonderful home for your next vacation. We can’t wait to return next year!

Reviewed By: Beth