Search Results > Property Detail

Jersey Girl

Address: 423 Spring Avenue | Type: Home | Location: Anna Maria

Bedrooms: 5

Bathrooms: 3

Sleeps: 12

Has Pool

View Gallery View Location

This property has been viewed 164 times in the last 3 days

Select your arrival date

Select your departure date

Reserve your stay

Arrival Date

Departure Date

Overview ↑↓

Welcome to this unique 5 bedroom Island Paradise!
Jersey Girl features a main house with 3 bedrooms and 2 baths along with an additional 2 bedrooms and 1 bath in the back house. It's perfectly suited for multigenerational family getaways providing generous space to spread out. Also, a wonderful layout for a bridal party getting ready for the big day!
The home features tasteful coastal-themed décor throughout that prioritizes guest comfort. Its gourmet kitchen and open floor plan are inviting family gatherings. Start your day at the breakfast bar and pick one of the many options for a great dinner together. The large table on the balcony offers alfresco style or dine pool side in the covered area under the front house.
Boasting over 1500 square feet of outdoor living in a secluded poolside setting, enjoy the warm tropical breezes. Explore the various pool side areas where you can relax on sun loungers, catch up with family by the premium quality Adirondacks or hang out in the covered sitting corner and watch some sports. Play a round of pool or have a Connect Four competition!

Conveniently located just a block away from Anna Maria's Pine Avenue, guests have easy access to fabulous shopping and dining options. Moreover, the Gulf or Bay Beaches, situated at each end of Spring Avenue, are within a short stroll. For those who prefer an active retreat, various rental options such as bikes, golf carts, GoPeds, and mopeds are available, allowing visitors to explore the tropical paradise hassle-free.

Water enthusiasts will delight in the array of activities on offer, including kayak and paddleboard rentals and guided tours. The Gulf Coast of Anna Maria boasts exceptional fishing opportunities, with two fishing piers and numerous charter captains available for hire.

HIGHLIGHTS

•    2140 sq. ft.
•    Private pool (30x13 ft)
•    Washer/dryer in main house
•    Separate Guest House
•    Pool Table and Outdoor Games

BEDROOMS

•    Sleeps 12
•    Primary Bedroom: King Ensuite
•    Second Bedroom: Queen
•    Third Bedroom: Bunk beds - twins
•    Fourth Bedroom: King (guest house)
•    Fifth Bedroom: Twins (guest house)

BATHROOMS

•    Ensuite Bathroom: Walk-in Shower
•    Second Bathroom: Walk-in Shower
•    Third Bathroom: Walk-in Shower (guest house)

EXTERIOR

The living room opens to the large balcony with outdoor dining which over looks the pool area and guest house. There is plenty of seating and loungers in the covered areas under both the main house and guest house. Other features include pool table, connect 4, an outdoor shower and gas grill.

There are 4 parking spaces designated for this property. The garage is not available to guests.
This property is protected by video surveillance in the front parking and gate area.

Optional pool heat up to 86º F is available from October to April at $150/week.
Pool equipment is locked for safety and controls must not be tampered with. Pool alarms are mandated per city licensing ordinance and cannot be disarmed. Pools are professionally serviced weekly. Debris due to tropical climate might occur in between service days. Pool equipment does not run 24 hours and water temperature can vary as pool heaters operate ONLY when the pool pump is running. Weather conditions may affect the temperature of the pool. When the ambient temperature falls below 60 degrees F, the pool heater may not function and even switch off.
Duncan Real Estate will expedite repairs of reported malfunctions, but no refund will be made for circumstances beyond our control.

Consider renting Jersey Girl's little sister Jersey Gal for a smaller party. It features the front house with 3 bedrooms, sleeping up to 8 guests.

This property is protected by video surveillance.

Following items are provided during your stay.

Amenities:
3-in-1 soap in each full bathroom
Hand soap
Laundry detergent sheets
Dish soap
Trash bags
Cleaning Spray
Dishwasher Pods

Linens:
2 bath towels per guest occupancy
1 beach towels per guest occupancy
1.5. wash cloths per guest occupancy
2 hand towels per bathroom
1 bath mat per full bathroom
2 kitchen towels
2 kitchen wash cloths

Starter Supplies:
2 rolls of toilet paper per bathroom
1 roll of paper towels
1 new sponge

Beach Amenities:
2-6 beach chairs *based on occupancy
Beach umbrella
Beach cart in private homes
Cooler

Please keep in mind that you are vacationing in a residential area. Please be a good neighbor by keeping the noise to a respectful level during the day and night. Excessive and unreasonable noise can deprive neighbors of the peaceful enjoyment of their private property.

Amenities ↑↓

• Balcony

• Bath Towels

• Beach Amenities

• Beach Towels

• Blender

• Board Games

• Breakfast Bar

• Carbon Monoxide Alarm

• Ceiling Fan Living Area

• Central A/C

• Central Heat

• Cleaning Kit

• Cookware

• Dining Table

• Dishwasher

• Drip Coffee maker

• Dryer

• Elevated

• Exterior Outlet

• Fire Extinguisher

• First Aid Kit

• Free Parking

• Garbage Disposal

• Hair Dryer

• Hangers

• High Speed WIFI

• Hot Water

• Ice Maker

• Iron

• Ironing Board

• Keurig

• Keyless Entry

• King bed

• Luxury Rental

• Microwave

• North End

• Outdoor Dining

• Outdoor Games

• Outdoor Shower

• 4 Parking Spots

• Pool

• Pool Alarms

• Pool Table

• Porch

• Private Pool

• Propane Grill

• Quality Linens

• Refrigerator

• Self Check In

• Short Stay

• Smoke Alarm

• Spa/Hot Tub

• Stove

• Sun Loungers

• Toaster

• 6 TV

• TV Streaming Only

• Washer

Request Info

Name(Required)

Email(Required)

Phone

Message(Required)

Reviews ↑↓

Submit a Review for Jersey Girl

Rental Review

Your Name(Required)

Enter your name as used on your reservation so we can validate your stay with us. This will NOT display on the website.

Your Email(Required)

Please enter your email address in case we need to contact you. This will NOT display on the website.

Public Information

The fields below may be publicly displayed on our website.

Display Name(Required)

Please enter your name as you wish it to appear on the website. Use initials if you wish privacy.

Review Title(Required)

Enter a short phrase to describe your rental experience.

Arrival Date(Required)

Enter the date you checked in for this rental. Select the month, day and year.

Month

Day

Year

Rating (1-5)(Required)

Select based on the # star rating you would give this property. 5 being the best.

Review

Leave your comments about this rental property.

Jersey Girl is the total package – you truly get to show up !!

Review Date: October 12, 2026

Vacation Date: October 5, 2026

"Jersey Girl was the perfect location, we had multiple families!! The cottage is perfect to give you a lil separate space when needed!! We had a small issue with the pool due to the hurricane in the gulf and a large amount of rain, they treated it very quickly and communicated immediately. Jersey Girl is the total package - you truly get to show up !! It’s obvious the care and thought they put into the property.

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

The house is conveniently located to shopping and restaurants all within walking distance!

Review Date: October 9, 2026

Vacation Date: September 30, 2026

"My family and I stayed at your beautiful house recently and it could not have been more perfect. The house is conveniently located to shopping and restaurants all within walking distance. The outdoor entertainment area was perfect for family, fun and entertaining.

Reviewed By: VRBO guest

Highly recommend, can’t wait to come back!

Review Date: August 19, 2026

Vacation Date: August 12, 2026

"Fully stocked and felt right at home! Having two separate buildings with one rental meant we had plenty of room for everyone in our party. Kitchen had absolutely everything you’d need. Pool, beach equipment, and outdoor furniture were awesome! The workout equipment and speakers were also a plus! Highly recommend, can’t wait to come back!

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

Wonderful Memories with Our Whole Family

Review Date: August 1, 2026

Vacation Date: July 14, 2026

"This was exactly the kind of vacation we hoped for as grandparents to five beach- and pool-loving boys. Our favorite part was watching them make memories together—hours in the pool, around the pool table, and simply having our whole family together for the week. The house had everything we needed. The kitchen was fully stocked, the laundry made it easy to keep towels and swimsuits fresh, and every bed, chair, and gathering space was comfortable. You could tell a lot of thought went into making guests feel at home. The cottage gave our family extra space and made it easy for everyone to spread out. We especially enjoyed the outdoor living spaces. Mornings began with coffee on the back porch, and the rest of the day was spent by the pool—sometimes cooling off in the water, but just as often relaxing in the covered seating, visiting, and watching all the fun. One of our favorite memories was sending the boys to Dips for ice cream. They happily walked there and back on their own—and even brought us back a cone. Jersey Girl is a beautiful, relaxing place where every generation can make wonderful memories together. We left feeling refreshed and already talking about coming back.

Reviewed By: Two happy grandparents

Host was very responsive!

Review Date: July 30, 2026

Vacation Date: July 6, 2026

"Host was very responsive.

Reviewed By: VRBO guest

They thought of everything!

Review Date: July 8, 2026

Vacation Date: July 1, 2026

"Our group of 11 felt right at home here for our visit. House had everything we needed. Beds were very comfortable. They thought of everything loved that they had everything we needed for the beach and pool. Easy to walk to the beach and shops and restaurants. We enjoyed the 4th of July parade also while there.

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

Ideal spot in AMI!

Review Date: June 23, 2026

Vacation Date: June 13, 2026

"Ideal spot in AMI, with easy access to the bay, gulf and shopping/restaurants. Duncan thought of everything with tailored playlists, custom games and suggested workouts. Incredible!

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

Great opportunity for a boys trip

Review Date: May 21, 2026

Vacation Date: May 20, 2026

"Location to beach is amazing and the night life was too-notch

Reviewed By: Darrell

The location is great – walking distance to the beach and local restaurants!

Review Date: May 4, 2026

Vacation Date: April 25, 2026

"Very enjoyable home with all amenities we needed as a family with kids 4 and 6 years old. The location is great - walking distance to the beach and local restaurants. Would definitely recommend it to anyone.

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

Location can’t be beat!

Review Date: March 31, 2026

Vacation Date: March 25, 2026

"Clean and very well stocked! Location can’t be beat. 1 block to Pine St and 4 blocks to beach. Will be back!

Reviewed By: Airbnb

Great setup and location!

Review Date: March 17, 2026

Vacation Date: March 6, 2026

"Everything went smoothly. Great setup and location. Very nice to be able to walk to shops, bars and restaurants.. even the beach!

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

*****

Review Date: February 7, 2026

Vacation Date: December 18, 2025

"*****

Reviewed By: VRBO guest

Our family has officially found our go-to house on Anna Maria!

Review Date: December 2, 2025

Vacation Date: November 21, 2025

"Our family has officially found our go-to house on Anna Maria - Jersey Girl! We had the absolute best time during our stay over Thanksgiving. The house was perfectly suited for our family with ages ranging 3-70+. The cottage gave everyone their own space. The main house was stocked to perfection and we easily hosted a Thanksgiving seafood feast. The pool deck and hang out area was a blast. Easy walking to Pine and the beach. My father-in-law enjoyed playing pickleball at the community center just steps away from the house. My mother-in-law and I enjoyed the seasonal farmers market, also steps from the house. We can’t wait to come back again!

Reviewed By: Duncan guest

Would recommend to anyone!

Review Date: September 3, 2025

Vacation Date: August 28, 2025

"Great place to stay, no complaints would recommend to anyone!

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

The property was centrally located, making it super convenient to explore the area!

Review Date: August 11, 2025

Vacation Date: August 3, 2025

"Anna Maria island is great. The property was centrally located, making it super convenient to explore the area. One of the best parts was how walkable everything was—the beach was just a short stroll away, and Pine Street, with all its shops and restaurants, was also within easy walking distance.

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

Great walkable location to the beach and restaurants!

Review Date: August 4, 2025

Vacation Date: July 31, 2025

"We enjoyed our stay at the Jersey girl. It’s in a great walkable location to the beach and restaurants. The island does not have great parking so a golf cart seems like a must while you’re there. The kitchen is well stocked with all the necessities so it was easy to enjoy meals as a big group. The pool area has everything you need to enjoy the outdoor space.

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

Perfect Family Getaway – A Slice of Paradise

Review Date: July 17, 2025

Vacation Date: July 10, 2025

"We just wrapped up an incredible 5-day stay at Jersey Girl on Anna Maria Island, and it was everything we hoped for—and more! The layout of the property is perfect for families or groups. The main house is beautifully kept, with all the comforts of home, and just across the pool is a separate cottage with two bedrooms and its own bathroom with a shower. It was ideal for giving the kids or grandparents a bit of space while still staying connected. It honestly felt like our own private resort. The pool area was a dream—warm, clean, and surrounded by palm trees and peace. We spent tons of time swimming, relaxing, and grilling out in the evenings. The house also had a small workout area, which was a nice bonus for staying active during the trip. One of the absolute highlights was our experience at Waterfront Restaurant, just a block up the street. They offer a catch-and-cook option, which made our kids’ fishing charter even more exciting. We caught trout on our trip, and the restaurant prepared it beautifully for dinner. It was such a special moment seeing the kids enjoy the catch they worked for! Jersey Girl has the perfect balance of comfort, location, and island charm. We made so many great memories and can’t wait to come back again. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a relaxing, family-friendly beach escape!

Reviewed By: Katie

The house has everything you could possibly need!

Review Date: June 18, 2025

Vacation Date: June 13, 2025

"Had a great trip to Jersey Girl. The house has everything you could possibly need. I loved all the beach gear available to use during my stay. I also loved having access to the washer and dryer and all of the laundry supplies. The Jersey Girl has a great location. It is a very short 5 minute walk to the bay to watch the sunrise and a short 10 minute walk to the beach to watch the sunset. The best of both worlds.

Reviewed By: Amanda KT

Coming back!

Review Date: May 28, 2025

Vacation Date: May 15, 2025

"We had an amazing stay. Main house had room to entertain and a fully stocked kitchen. The bunk room is great for the vacation sleepovers. The additional back house is convenient and allowed us to accommodate everyone comfortably. Both seemed recently updated and very clean and bright. The outdoor area is spectacular. Many hours spent in the pool! There was room to relax in the sun, rest in the shade, enjoy a drink at the Tiki bar or cook out on the grill! Location is a short ride or walk to beach and many restaurants near by. We will be coming back!

Reviewed By: Thomas

Amazing Stay

Review Date: May 22, 2025

Vacation Date: May 17, 2025

"We had an unforgettable stay at Jersey Girl. The property was absolutely perfect for our group. Spacious, beautifully maintained and thoughtfully designed for both relaxation and fun. The main house offered plenty of room for everyone to spread out comfortably. The additional cottage house is such a bonus, perfect for added privacy. We spent hours soaking up the sun, lounging poolside. The large pool area felt like our own private resort. Location could not be better. It is just a short walk to the gorgeous beaches. We also loved how easy it was to explore the nearby restaurants, shops and even a bit of local nightlife. It was the perfect island getaway!

Reviewed By: Darrell

We would definitely come back for our next visit.

Review Date: April 4, 2025

Vacation Date: March 15, 2025

"We had 5 adults and 4 children stay there for a week. The main kitchen/dining/living area had plenty of room for all of us to spend time together. The kitchen had plenty of space and great cookware, and 2 blenders! 2 of the bedrooms being in the seperate structure allowed for some needed time apart. The pool area had a good mix of sun and shade and lots of covered table space for meals outside by the pool. There were lots of beach supplies, 8 chairs and a wagon to get it there. We would definitely come back for our next visit.

Reviewed By: Airbnb guest

We love Jersey Girl!

Review Date: August 22, 2024

Vacation Date: June 23, 2024

"My family and I have been renting the Jersey Girl for an annual trip for the past 5 years and we LOVE the Jersey Girl. There is a main house and there is a guest house with a pool in between. It's perfect for larger groups because there is plenty of room to entertain and hang out together, but the home also provides an opportunity for everyone to have their own space. We love having the ability to have half the group stay at home and swim in the pool or head to the beach. We always feel like it's our home away from home when we come to stay for the week because the house is clean, the kitchen is fully stocked for nights we decide to stay in and cook. The Jersey Girl is in a prime location to walk to the beach, all the shops in town, and most importantly for my family the donut shop. Cannot recommend the Jersey Girl enough for your stay in AMI.

Reviewed By: Lindsey

Fantastic Stay!

Review Date: August 9, 2024

Vacation Date: April 22, 2024

"I had a fantastic stay at the Jersey Girl on Anna Maria Island. It was my first visit to Anna Maria, and the experience exceeded all expectations! The house was immaculate and beautifully decorated, capturing the perfect beach house vibe that’s ideal for a seaside retreat. Located on a quiet street with friendly neighbors, the property is conveniently within walking distance of coffee shops, sweet treats, and shopping. The layout is particularly impressive, featuring a main house and a smaller house nestled around a lovely swimming pool. It’s perfect for families or a group of friends looking for a memorable getaway. I highly recommend this stay—it's a true gem!

Reviewed By: Kerri

Wonderful Experience!

Review Date: August 8, 2024

Vacation Date: March 21, 2024

"We recently had the wonderful experience of staying at the Jersey Girl on Anna Maria, it was an exceptional experience from start to finish! The house was exactly as described, spotlessly clean, spacious and beautifully decorated. The location was perfect, walking distance to the beach, one block off Pine avenue which is the main shopping area, while still being in a quiet, peaceful neighborhood. The host was incredibly responsive and provided clear instructions making the check in process a breeze. The amenities were top notch, fully equipped kitchen, comfortable beds and pillows, a warm and inviting outdoor area with a pool and lanai. The icing on the cake was the lovely guest cottage. Overall, this was one of the best rental experiences we’ve had! We would highly recommend this property to anyone looking for a very comfortable and enjoyable stay. We will definitely be back!

Reviewed By: Tricia and Tony

Everything We Needed

Review Date: August 7, 2024

Vacation Date: April 20, 2024

"We had the most amazing stay at Jersey Girl! We have booked this rental before and are always impressed with this home. It was a perfect distance to the beach. We also loved having the option to hang by the pool too! The home was fully stocked with everything we needed to make meals for our large group. It is great that there is a cottage so anyone with young children or someone who needs to go to bed early can be separate from the larger group. We will definitely be booking again!

Reviewed By: Caroline

10/10

Review Date: August 6, 2024

Vacation Date: June 25, 2024

"My wife and I stayed here for our honeymoon in June and it was exactly what we were looking for! The pool provides a lovely, secluded getaway once you get back from the beach (which was only a short walk away!). PLENTY of space to have a large group stay in the house if that is what you are looking for. The property is close enough to the beach and restaurants but not too close to the "main drag". The ice cream shop around the corner is a nice bonus!! Checking in and out was such a breeze. Such a nice, quiet place to stay and we will definitely be back!

Reviewed By: Doug

Checked all the boxes!

Review Date: June 27, 2024

Vacation Date: March 23, 2024

"I had the opportunity to stay at The Jersey Girl on Anna Maria Island in March. This home checked all of the boxes. You could not ask for a better location. A short stroll to restaurants and shops as well as a hop, skip and a jump to the beach. Very convenient! We loved the main floor open concept which had all the amenities you could ask for. Vacationing with 3 other couples we had ample room. Plenty of gathering spaces in the kitchen and lounging area plus a large outdoor dining space off the kitchen area which was great for evening dinners in the beautiful Florida weather. A beautiful pool located between the main house and guest quarters was a bonus. Additional relaxing areas surrounding the pool provided options to be in the sun or the shade. This area was quite peaceful and tranquil with the gorgeous landscaping. This home was fully equipped and did not disappoint in anyway. It was absolutely a pleasure staying at The Jersey Girl and would highly recommend!!!

Reviewed By: Linda M

The best week!

Review Date: March 9, 2024

Vacation Date: March 1, 2024

"Thank you for hosting us at the Jersey Girl for the week. Your home is so welcoming it feels like a home away from home. We had a fabulous time soaking in all the beauty that AMI has to offer. We don't have these wonderful beaches back in Minnesota! We had the best week here!

Reviewed By: The Wards

Joyful and Relaxing

Review Date: March 9, 2024

Vacation Date: October 1, 2023

"Thank you for one of the most joyful, relaxing family weeks we've ever had! Hopefully we will be back to visit again for more cooking, Uno and time on Anna Maria at Jersey Girl!

Reviewed By: The Rathburns

Exceeded our Expectations

Review Date: March 9, 2024

Vacation Date: March 30, 2023

"We had such a great week and really enjoyed staying in your beautiful home! Everything was perfect and actually exceeded our expectations. The space by the pool was used all week and enjoyed by all. We would certainly stay here again and would highly recommend to friends and family.

Reviewed By: The Haecker Family

Beautiful Home

Review Date: March 9, 2024

Vacation Date: March 11, 2023

"Thank you for sharing your beautiful home and this fabulous Island with us. Gorgeous weather made for a great week!

Reviewed By: The Harrison Family